MC Awards Tie-Breaker Thread: Best Song

[Spinal]

This is a MC Awards tie-breaker thread. The winner will be awarded Best Song. Vote by posting your choice below. If you voted for one of these songs in the original ballot, you are ineligible. Anyone else can vote, even if you didn't submit a full ballot initially.

Those who are ineligible to vote in this thread:
Lazlo
Zac Efron
Dukefrukem
Spinal
Peng
Henry Gale

Your options:


"Always Remember Us This Way", A Star is Born


"Shallow", A Star is Born

This vote will end 24 hours after the timestamp of this post. Any votes cast after that time will not count. If this vote ends in a tie, the last vote cast will be thrown out.

[baby doll]

I vote for "Shallow." Good thing I've seen both of the nominated films.

[Ezee E]

Fine....... Shallow it is.

[Dukefrukem]

That is clearly the inferior song guys.

[Henry Gale]

I know I can't vote again but it was only ever gonna be Shallow for me.

It's the defining scene of the movie that clinches the goodwill its second half threatens to take away from it but never quite can. It was also the emotional high point of the whole movie for me and I then purposely avoided it in its radio-heavy overexposure phase which made the Oscar performance even fresher and more effective.

I really do like the other song but I don't know if I can even remember where in the movie it's performed. (At Ally's concert after the garage scene?) Maybe if I'd only listened to the soundtrack without the film I'd have had a different vote, but I looked at it as a "Best use of an original song in a film" type of award and went the Shallow route.

[Ivan Drago]

IN THE SHALLASHALALALALALALOOOOOOW

[Spinal]

Official Winner

BEST SONG

"Shallow", A Star is Born