Yeah, can't say I'm sure what to make of Winter's Bone. Hawkes and Lawrence are great, but one thing I kept thinking was that for for such an independent movie, it oddly felt like the sort of things where too many different hands came in and tinkered the plotline over time, having the script in a place where it seemed like whatever point it was trying to make was lost.
The ending is especially strange, almost as if it had one more scene taken away from the end to add some sort of irony or sense of a huge journey to the end of it. But instead, it leaves everything more or less where they were at the beginning, and without giving much catharsis along with it. For such strongly drawn characters, they don't have moments to act as much else but victims to circumstances beyond their control, and not even in particularly compelling ways. The only exciting parts for me seemed to be when the film has strangely mislead me into thinking it was going in a direction it wasn't. Instead, it just finds itself clinging to one emotional spot, never really adding many layers to it.
So overall disappointing, though mostly well made. I'm just not sure how much of that comes from the reception it's had up to me actually seeing it. Aside from the performances, there isn't much I can say stands out here. The fact that it's going to likely be such an awards darling in the next few months really puzzles me.