Match Cut Directors Consensus - Preston Sturges

[StanleyK]

I'd post my usual header here but for some reason the threads I want to quote it from give me this error:

Function name must be a string on line 1566 in /home/artboile/public_html/mcvb4/includes/class_bbcode.php
#0 /home/artboile/public_html/mcvb4/includes/class_bbcode.php(1021): vB_BbCodeParser->parse_array(Array, 1, 1, 0)
#1 /home/artboile/public_html/mcvb4/includes/class_bbcode.php(542): vB_BbCodeParser->parse_bbcode('[quote]No guara...', 1, 1, 0)
#2 /home/artboile/public_html/mcvb4/includes/class_bbcode.php(456): vB_BbCodeParser->do_parse('[quote]No guara...', 0, 1, 1, 1, true, false, 'on_nl2br', false, 1)
#3 /home/artboile/public_html/mcvb4/includes/class_postbit.php(1242): vB_BbCodeParser->parse('[quote]No guara...', 2, '1', false, NULL, NULL, false, 'on_nl2br')
#4 /home/artboile/public_html/mcvb4/includes/class_postbit.php(329): vB_Postbit_Post->parse_bbcode()
#5 /home/artboile/public_html/mcvb4/showthread.php(1096): vB_Postbit->construct_postbit(Array)
#6 {main}



Anyway, post your ratings. If there are enough ratings at the end of a week or two, I'll tally them.

[StanleyK]

The Great McGinty - 5.5
Christmas in July - 7
The Lady Eve - 8.5
Sullivan's Travels - 8.5
The Palm Beach Story - 8.5
The Miracle of Morgan's Creek - 7
Hail the Conquering Hero - 7
The Great Moment - 4
The Sin of Harold Diddlebock - 7
Unfaithfully Yours - 4
The Beautiful Blonde from Bashful Bend - 4

[baby doll]

Unfaithfully Yours (1948): 6, but it's been about fifteen years
Hail the Conquering Hero! (1944): 8
The Miracle of Morgan's Creek (1944): 9, possibly a 10 once I give it a second look
The Palm Beach Story (1942): 6 (I still can't figure out why I don't like this more)
Sullivan's Travels (1942): I need to re-watch this, but if my memories from fifteen years ago are reliable, a 4
The Lady Eve (1941): 9
The Great McGinty (1940): 6, but I can barely remember it

[Peng]

The Great McGinty (1940) - 7
Christmas in July (1940) - 7.5
The Lady Eve (1941) - 8.5
Sullivan's Travels (1941) - 8.5 (my fav)
The Palm Beach Story (1942) - 8.5
The Miracle of Morgan's Creek (1944) - 7
Hail the Conquering Hero (1944) - 8.5
Unfaithfully Yours (1948) - 8

Uncounted bonus round (writing credits):

The Power and the Glory (1933) - 7.5
The Good Fairy (1935) - 7
Easy Living (1937) - 7.5
Remember the Night (1940) - 8

[StanleyK]

I'm sure more than two people have seen this guy's movies.

[Mr. McGibblets]

Most of these ratings are 10-15 years old. The only one I've rewatched recently was Morgan's Creek which I liked a lot less than the first time I saw it.

The Great McGinty - 8
Christmas in July - 7
The Lady Eve - 8
Sullivan's Travels - 9
The Palm Beach Story - 8
The Miracle of Morgan's Creek - 6
Hail the Conquering Hero - 6
The Great Moment - 5
The Sin of Harold Diddlebock - 5
Unfaithfully Yours - 8
The Beautiful Blonde from Bashful Bend - 7

[Dead & Messed Up]

The Lady Eve - 8
Sullivan's Travels - 7

[Irish]

Christmas in July - 10
The Lady Eve - 8
Sullivan's Travels - 10