Log in

View Full Version : The Guernica Tree (Arrabal, 1975)



Spinal
03-24-2008, 09:38 PM
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v696/joel_harmon/more/dvdmovie_11633_front_1175.jpg

The Guernica Tree (Arrabal, 1975)

Fernando Arrabal’s take on the 1937 Nazi bombing of Guernica during the Spanish Civil War is to film what Picasso’s Guernica is to the world of art. Both are works that draw from the horrors of war and then use evocative symbols and purposeful distortions of reality to communicate feelings of anger, sadness and disgust. The film is set, not in Guernica, but rather in a nearby village called Villa Ramiro. There, Bohemians dance in the streets in elaborate costumes and a local artist pulls shocking pranks on both government officials and church goers. Up in a tower of stone, the count coldly lords over the citizens. From the very beginning, the seeds of conflict are planted.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v696/joel_harmon/more/500px-PicassoGuernica5B15D.jpg
Picasso's Guernica

When a beautiful woman arrives in town, riding sidesaddle, she is chased by three Fascist thugs intent on raping her. She flees into a small deserted house. When the men find her and close in on her, she reveals a handful of vipers in her hands, which she flings at her attackers in self-defense. This incident is a metaphor for the large-scale conflict that serves as the film’s center. The woman’s name is Vandale, a survivor of the Guernica bombings who has come to Villa Ramiro to provide inspiration and leadership to the rebels who wish to overthrow their oppressors.

After the rebels topple the local government officials and desecrate the nearby church in ways that would not seem out of place in a de Sade novel, Vandale rallies the villagers and urges them to take up arms against the approaching armies intent on definitively crushing the uprising. Also involved is a local academic who preaches pacifism and believes in ideas that are transported “on the wings of a dove.” However, in the face of enemy artillery, he struggles to translate his ideals into tangible action, worrying that he has cornered himself into passivity.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v696/joel_harmon/more/603.jpg

Arrabal directs with equal parts creativity, rage and vulgarity. It is worth noting that his grudge against fascism was developed first-hand in his childhood when his father, a political enemy of Franco, was placed in a labor camp for life. Though it is believed that he escaped from prison in 1941, he disappeared forever. With that context, it is perhaps easier to understand the perverse glee Arrabal takes with debasing the film’s oppressors, often through sexual or scatological imagery. Holding the film together is an underlying sense of poetry and the masterful use of allegorical characters. On rare occasions, Arrabal lapses into scenes that are either insincere or obvious audience bait for moral outrage. However, for the most part, The Guernica Tree is a stirring, captivating plea for humanity and courage in the face of governmental cruelties.

[***1/2]

Sven
03-24-2008, 09:51 PM
Sounds very good. I will put this on The List.

Russ
03-24-2008, 09:58 PM
Man, I really hate that I didn't spring for the box set that includes Guernica Tree. Your description really does a good job of noting the similarities in this film with his earlier works, Viva La Muerte and I Will Walk Like a Crazy Horse. You seem to prefer GT and I would like to hear your thoughts on how you feel it compares, especially on how Arrabal may have matured as a director.

Spinal
03-24-2008, 10:38 PM
Man, I really hate that I didn't spring for the box set that includes Guernica Tree. Your description really does a good job of noting the similarities in this film with his earlier works, Viva La Muerte and I Will Walk Like a Crazy Horse. You seem to prefer GT and I would like to hear your thoughts on how you feel it compares, especially on how Arrabal may have matured as a director.

I would be better able to answer this if I could remember Crazy Horse more clearly. I remember enjoying it quite a bit, but I'm at the point now where I may as well not have seen it at all because I can barely remember a thing. Viva La Muerte is clearer in my mind, and while I really hate equating maturity with a move towards linearity, I think there's no question that Guernica Tree has a better defined sense of purpose. The abrasive visual shocks are perhaps easier to pinpoint to a single 'meaning', but I do not think that they are necessarily less potent for it. I see a parallel to Jodorowsky's work of the same era in the artistic progression of these three Arrabal films. As great as these guys were at disturbing an audience and messing with our expectations, it seems that both The Holy Mountain and The Guernica Tree move towards letting the audience in more. I don't know that it is necessarily a conscious concession, so much as it is both men really narrowing in on what it is they want to communicate. Arrabal doesn't quite match the dizzying heights of Jodorowsky's visual onslaught, but who does? There's still plenty here to please someone looking for a filmmaker working in a similar mode.

Plus, his DVD extras are always really funny. On this one, he goes to Grauman's Chinese Theater during some Hollywood event and starts asking people if they have heard of Picasso's Guernica, Salvador Dali or Arrabal.

I wish I had kept the DVD to do my own screen captures. There don't seem to be many on-line.

Russ
03-24-2008, 11:14 PM
I'd agree about the Jodorowsky comparison re: artistic progression; Crazy Horse breaks free of the more rigid political criticisms of Viva La Muerte and injects a bit of whimsy amongst the more broadly-painted societal critique.


Plus, his DVD extras are always really funny.
They're hysterical. I especially like the one where he interrupts his interviewer to accept..and engage in..a phone call from God.


I wish I had kept the DVD to do my own screen captures. There don't seem to be many on-line.

Do you remember the burning penis from Crazy Horse? That's a memorable shot. Here's one of my favorite images from Viva La Muerte:


http://img266.imageshack.us/img266/5230/turkeyeditedky6.jpg

Spinal
03-24-2008, 11:34 PM
They're hysterical. I especially like the one where he interrupts his interviewer to accept..and engage in..a phone call from God.


Yes! Is that the one where he is inexplicably holding a chair in front of him throughout the entire interview? Man, what a weird, cool guy. I started re-reading his short play Picnic on the Battlefield over my lunch break. It's about a soldier on the front lines whose parents show up unexpectedly to have a picnic.

Love the turkey!

MadMan
03-25-2008, 02:20 AM
I have never heard of this film. Thanks to your review Spinal I will put this film on my long "To See" list and keep my eye out for it. I'm sure its on Netflix at least.

Spinal
03-25-2008, 04:22 PM
I have never heard of this film. Thanks to your review Spinal I will put this film on my long "To See" list and keep my eye out for it. I'm sure its on Netflix at least.

It is on Netflix. I'd definitely like to hear what you think if you get around to seeing it.

Raiders
03-25-2008, 04:41 PM
I'm completely unfamiliar with Arrabal. Can't say this film or any of his particularly spark my interest, but your mention of Jodorowsky does make me a little curious.

Spinal
03-25-2008, 04:45 PM
I'm completely unfamiliar with Arrabal. Can't say this film or any of his particularly spark my interest, but your mention of Jodorowsky does make me a little curious.

Yeah, those two and Roland Topor used to hang out causing trouble (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panic_Movement) back in the day.

Russ
03-25-2008, 10:13 PM
Wonder how many realize Topor's hand in the screenplay of the animated classic, Fantastic Planet, which he co-wrote, or that he played Renfield in Herzog's Nosferatu?

And Spinal, did you know that he did the incredibly bizarre animation in the opening credits of Arrabal's Viva La Muerte (which was musically set to a children's singalong tune)?

Spinal
03-25-2008, 10:15 PM
And Spinal, did you know that he did the incredibly bizarre animation in the opening credits of Arrabal's Viva La Muerte (which was musically set to a children's singalong tune)?

I didn't realize that, but I definitely remember how vivid and arresting that animation was.

Russ
03-25-2008, 10:26 PM
I didn't realize that, but I definitely remember how vivid and arresting that animation was.
Yeah, and not really animation per se (I was wrong, they looked to be pencil or charcoal drawings), but it was the freakiest stuff I've seen this side of Hieronymus Bosch.

Spinal
03-25-2008, 10:32 PM
Yeah, and not really animation per se (I was wrong, they looked to be pencil or charcoal drawings), but it was the freakiest stuff I've seen this side of Hieronymus Bosch.

If memory serves, the camera just floats around a still picture finding all the details within the whole. Lots of demons and torture and all that.

MadMan
03-26-2008, 01:17 AM
It is on Netflix. I'd definitely like to hear what you think if you get around to seeing it.Will do. I think I'll finally break down and get Netflix, especially since I watch a lot of movies during the summer.

Qrazy
03-26-2008, 04:02 AM
Very cool, will look into it. It's always nice to hear a new name/film, there's so many buried gems out there. one of the things I love most about film and having watched film addictedly for about a decade now... starting to feel like a treasure hunter.

Russ
03-26-2008, 03:21 PM
I'm happy that this thread has sparked some interest in Arrabal's films. The fact that his output is so sparse is perhaps why he flies under the radar and most people are unfamiliar with him. Anyone who even remotely enjoys Jodorowsky's films would be well served to check out Arrabal's films as well. I went back and dug up an old review of Crazy Horse:

I Will Walk Like a Crazy Horse (Fernando Arrabal, 1973)

Well, I can safely tell you this much: some of you will find this extremely pretentious and difficult to watch; others, like me, will sing this movie's praises and recognize Arrabal as a brilliantly twisted genius. This was Arrabal's second film and is less a political statement this time around, focusing more on spiritual themes. This film is so over the top, almost self-consciously so and to the point of distraction at times; but apart from this criticism there is little I can find fault with here. This was my first Arrabal film and it unquestionably belongs to the pantheon of "surreal masterpieces" alongside the likes of Lynch, Bunuel, and his co-conspirators in the Panic movement, Jodorowsky and Topor. The symbolism in this film is more heavy-handed than even his closest comparison, Jodorowsky, but Arrabal is a master at bringing amazingly indelible images to the screen. What surprised me was how adept Arrabal is behind the camera; he has an incredible natural instinct for filmmaking and I can't understand why he never pursued it fulltime. Before I give this film my full-fledged recommendation, be forewarned: when you see those "not for the squeamish" or "unrated for grotesque violence" caveats, it would be wise to tread lightly here...this is the taboo highball from hell: 2 oz Jodorowsky, 1 finger Waters, splash of H.G. Lewis...and the rest completely original stuff that will engage your brain and distend your jaw. pro (+) ...those who enjoy surreal cinema must see this film.