Match Cut Director Consensus - George Cukor

[Ezee E]

Rate one of the biggest studio directors from the 1900's.

http://old.oscars.org/mhl/sc/images/cukor.jpg

He only directed one scene in Gone With The Wind, so it's really not his project, but I figure it should be rated anyway.

[Adam]

The Philadelphia Story 7
Adam's Rib 6.5

[dreamdead]

I have A Star is Born and The Women to view still, though.

Holiday - 7 (the drunk brother annoys me, as this era of Hollywood is so facile about the ills of drinking)
The Philadelphia Story - 8 (I dislike Hepburn, but Grant and Stewart are awesome together)
Born Yesterday - 6
A Star is Born - 7
My Fair Lady - 6

[Weeping_Guitar]

One Hour with You - 8.5
Sylvia Scarlett - 6
Dinner at Eight - 8
Holiday - 10
The Women - 3
The Philadelphia Story - 9
Gaslight - 6
Adam's Rib - 7
Born Yesterday - 7
It Should Happen to You - 7
My Fair Lady - 5

[thefourthwall]

He only directed one scene in Gone With The Wind, so it's really not his project, but I figure it should be rated anyway.

So are we rating just that scene? or the movie as a whole?

[Ezee E]

So are we rating just that scene? or the movie as a whole?
Ha. We'll go with the movie as a whole.

[Spinal]

The Philadelphia Story - 6.5
My Fair Lady - 5.5

I'll wait for the Victor Fleming consensus for GWTW.

[Raiders]

We'll do Victor Fleming eventually, so it seems silly to do GWTW. I'll exclude it.

Dinner at Eight (1933) 6.5
Camille (1936) 7.5
Holiday (1938) 8.0
The Women (1939) 6.5
The Philadelphia Story (1940) 7.5
Gaslight (1944) 6.0
Adam's Rib (1949) 5.0
Pat and Mike (1952) 5.5
A Star is Born (1954) 7.0
My Fair Lady (1964) 6.5

[Yxklyx]

One Hour with You (co-director)- 8
Little Women - 7
Dinner at Eight - 6
Sylvia Scarlett - 7
Camille - 2
Holiday - 8
The Women - 9
Gone with the Wind (co-director) - 6
The Philadelphia Story - 8
Gaslight - 5
A Double Life - 7
Adam's Rib - 6
Born Yesterday - 6
The Marrying Kind - 8
A Star is Born - 8
My Fair Lady - 6

[Mysterious Dude]

David Copperfield - 7
Romeo and Juliet - 5.5
The Philadelphia Story - 6
Gaslight - 10
A Double Life - 7
Adam's Rib - 5.5
Born Yesterday - 5
A Star Is Born - 7.5
My Fair Lady - 6.5

[megladon8]

Dinner at Eight - 7.5
Holiday - 10
The Women - 8.5
The Philadelphia Story - 10
Adam's Rib - 9
My Fair Lady - 4

[jenniferofthejungle]

Dinner at Eight - 8
Little Women - 6
Manhattan Melodrama - 6
Camille - 7
Holiday - 7
The Women - 8
The Philadelphia Story - 10
A Woman's Face - 6
Gaslight - 8
Edward, My Son - 5.5
Adam's Rib - 9
Born Yesterday - 8.5
Pat and Mike - 5
It Should Happen To You - 7
A Star Is Born - 7
My Fair Lady - 8
Rich and Famous - 5

[soitgoes...]

Holiday (1938) - 7.0
The Philadelphia Story (1940) - 10
Adam’s Rib (1949) - 6.0
My Fair Lady (1964) - 5.0

Ditto in thinking GWTW should wait for a Fleming consensus.

[Derek]

Holiday - 8.0
The Philadelphia Story - 8.5
Gaslight - 6.5
Adam's Rib - 6.0
A Star Is Born - 8.0

[Boner M]

The Philadelphia Story - 7
Gaslight - 6.5

[B-side]

Nada. :\

[baby doll]

Gone With the Wind (1939) [3]
The Philidelphia Story (1940) [6]

I need to rewatch A Star Is Born. Other than that, the only film of his I really want to see is Sylvia Scarlett.

[Wryan]

If Dinner at Eight is what I remember it being, it was insufferable.

Dinner at Eight - 3
Little Women - 7
Camille - 6
The Women - 8
The Philadelphia Story - 9
Gaslight - 8
Adam's Rib - 9
Pat and Mike - 6
A Star Is Born - 7
My Fair Lady - 7

This is not really my rating system, but it seems to be the rage above, so I tailored.

[angrycinephile]

The Philadelphia Story - 7

[Kurosawa Fan]

Holiday - 8.5
The Philadelphia Story - 8.5
It Should Happen to You - 5.0

[Ezee E]

Holiday - 7

[thefourthwall]

The Philadelphia Story - 7.5
A Star is Born - 8
My Fair Lady - 8.5

[Philosophe_rouge]

Dinner at Eight 6
Little Women 9.5
Sylvia Scarlett 7
Camille 8
Holiday 8
The Women 6.5
The Philadelphia Story 8
Gaslight 7.5
Adam's Rib 6
Born Yesterday 7
My Fair Lady 5

[Qrazy]

The Philadelphia Story 7.5

Only watched half of Adam's Rib but I didn't like it (the half I saw was roughly a 4 or so).

[Ezee E]

RESULTS:
1. Holiday - 8.05 (11)
2. The Philadelphia Story - 7.95 (19)
3. A Star is Born - 7.44 (8)
4. Little Women - 7.38 (4)
5. Gaslight - 7.06 (9)
6. The Women - 6.92 (6)
7. Adam's Rib - 6.6 (10)
8. Born Yesterday - 6.58 (6)
9. Dinner at Eight - 6.43 (7)
10. Camille - 6.1 (5)
11. My Fair Lady - 6.08 (12)

-David Coppperfield - 7 (1)
-Romeo and Juliet - 5.5 (1)
-One Hour With You - 8.25 (2)
-Sylvia Scarlett - 6.66 (3)
-Manhattan Melodrama - 7 (1)
-A Women's Face - 6 (1)
-A Double Life - 6.5 (2)
-Edward, My Son - 9 (1)
-Rich and Famous - 5 (1)
-Pat and Mike - 5.5 (3)
-It Should Happen To You - 6.33 (3)
-The Marrying Kind - 8 (1)

= 7.09