Match Cut Directors Consensus - Carol Reed

[StanleyK]

http://auteurs_production.s3.amazonaw s.com/cast_member_images/317/Carol_Reed.png

Filmography (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0715346/#director)

Rules (http://www.match-cut.org/showpost.php?p=122142&postcount=1)

[dreamdead]

The Fallen Idol - 6
The Third Man - 9.5

I love a lot of FI's cinematography, but the story feels so slight to me that I can't rate it any higher.

[Morris Schæffer]

The Third Man - 8.5

[Ezee E]

The Third Man - 8.5
The Agony and the Ecstasy - 3.5

For many years, I thought Carol Reed was a woman. I know I'm not the only one.

[StanleyK]

The Third Man - 10

[ledfloyd]

Odd Man Out - 9
The Third Man - 10

[Mysterious Dude]

Odd Man Out - 8
The Fallen Idol - 7
The Third Man - 8.5
Oliver! - 5.5



For many years, I thought Carol Reed was a woman.

I was going to post this exact same sentence.

[Adam]

The Third Man, 8.5
Our Man In Havana, 7.5

[ledfloyd]

add me to those who thought he was a woman for a good while.

[Weeping_Guitar]

Odd Man Out - 8
The Fallen Idol - 7.5
The Third Man - 10
Our Man in Havana - 9

[Yxklyx]

Odd Man Out - 10
The Fallen Idol - 9
The Third Man - 10
Oliver! - 7

[Raiders]

Night Train to Munich (1940) 6.0
The Fallen Idol (1948) 9.0
The Third Man (1949) 8.0
Oliver! (1968) 5.5

[Spinal]

The Third Man - 8.5
Oliver! - 7.5

[Bosco B Thug]

The Third Man - 8.5

[Boner M]

Odd Man Out - 8.5
The Third Man - 8

[Pop Trash]

The Third Man -9

[Winston*]

The Fallen Idol - 8
The Third Man - 8

The Fallen Idol is great. Really gives a good depiction of how annoying children are.

[Grouchy]

For many years, I thought Carol Reed was a woman. I know I'm not the only one.
Same thing happened to me with Dana Andrews.

The Third Man - 10

[B-side]

The Third Man - 8

Chalk me up as part of the list of folks that thought he was a woman for quite a while. Got corrected a few months ago.

[Mysterious Dude]

Same thing happened to me with Dana Andrews.

Maybe we should make a list of men who we used to think were women.

1. Carol Reed
2. Dana Anders
3. Leslie Howard
4. Lindsay Anderson

Who else?

[Grouchy]

Who else?
Harmony Korine.

[Philosophe_rouge]

Odd man out 10
The Fallen Idol 8
The third Man 10
Oliver! 7.5

[Ivan Drago]

add me to those who thought he was a woman for a good while.

Same here.

The Third Man - 9
Oliver! - 6

[Derek]

Odd Man Out - 7.5
The Third Man - 8.5

Also thought he was a she for a long time.

[Kurosawa Fan]

The Third Man - 8.5

[thefourthwall]

The Third Man - 9.5
Oliver! - 7.5

[Spinal]

Silly Match Cut. Women didn't direct mainstream films in the 40s.

[Raiders]

Silly Match Cut. Women didn't direct mainstream films in the 40s.

There was Dorothy Arzner and by 1950, Ida Lupino.

[Derek]

Silly Match Cut. Women didn't direct mainstream films in the 40s.

I never said I didn't feel stupid later and in a country as historically as progressive as England, who knows? ;)

[soitgoes...]

Odd Man Out (1947) - 8.0
The Fallen Idol (1948) - 8.0
The Third Man (1949) - 10
Our Man in Havana (1959) - 8.0
The Agony and the Ecstasy (1965) - 5.0

[Ezee E]

Oh yeah... The Agony and the Ecstasy. Updated. Ugh.

[MadMan]

The Third Man(1949)-11.0/10.0

[Kurious Jorge v3.1]

For many years, I thought Carol Reed was a woman. I know I'm not the only one.

TRUE DAT.

The Fallen Idol - 7.5
Third Man - 10

[StanleyK]

Results:

The Third Man - 9.080 (25)
Odd Man Out - 8.625 (8)
Fallen Idol - 7.778 (9)
Oliver! - 6.643 (7)

Average: 8.032

Didn't make it:

Our Man in Havana - 8.167 (3)
Night Train to Munich - 6.000 (1)
The Agony and the Ecstasy - 4.250 (2)

Most seen: soitgoes...