PDA

View Full Version : Film Swap: Citizen Dog



Spinal
11-21-2007, 12:32 AM
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v696/joel_harmon/citizen20dog204.jpg

Citizen Dog (Sasanatieng, 2004)

Recommended by: Sycophant

I appreciate a film that lets you know from the very beginning that you are going to be in good hands. The bold, saturated colors of Citizen Dog are immediately arresting as we begin in a comic dream sequence where the protagonist, Pod, meets his grandmother in front of a vivid, pleasantly artificial landscape. After she offers a cryptic prophecy, an off-screen narrator introduces us to Pod’s quirks and personality traits. As we are introduced to Pod’s highly stylized environment, see him work a tedious job at a sardine factory and learn about his habit of plugging in the fan when he means to plug in the iron, it becomes increasingly harder to believe that Thai director, Wisit Sasanatieng, has not at some point in his life watched Amelie. To be sure, the film’s first 15-20 minutes are an absolute delight, highlighted by a giddy and joyful opening credits sequence.

Pod is a country boy who, we are told, has no dream. After accepting a new job in the big city, he soon finds himself attracted to Jin, an obsessive-compulsive maid who may actually find joy and fulfillment in a job devoted to cleanliness. Jin is, however, difficult to get to know, as she constantly has her head in a book. One book, to be precise – a book with a plain white cover and written in a language that she does not understand. Jin, we will find, has a habit of making huge assumptions about the world around her, believing certain people or things are of great importance and impulsively acting according to those fantasies.

Pod, on the other hand, seems utterly intimidated and paralyzed by the hustle and bustle of the world around him. All around him, extraordinary things happen. Yet, he seems too timid to take an active role. After he meets Jin, she and her blue uniform are all that he can see. Sometimes, literally. Despite her frequent irrationality, there is something about her intensity and passion that he finds alluring. In the film’s central metaphor, Pod resists growing a tail, as his grandmother has predicted he would. Sasanatieng’s purpose is somewhat elusive; however, it seems that what Pod fears about becoming a ‘citizen dog’ is that he feels it means conformity and obedience. Pod resists going along with the crowd. Yet, his resistance is passive and unengaged. He must ultimately make a choice: either continue to bump up against the mainstream or find a way to exist within it.

Citizen Dog is filled with enough surprises, humor and visual delights to make it well worth watching. I’ve purposefully avoided mentioning some of the film’s most magical moments and sight gags. However, I did find that my interest and involvement in the journey did begin to wane about halfway through. It is a joy to be introduced to the film’s conventions, idiosyncrasies and central characters. About the time the guy who licks everybody and everything makes his appearance though, I was ready for the film to get a little bit more sincere and forthcoming with what it ultimately hoped to accomplish. Jin’s journey actually turned out to be more moving and meaningful to me than Pod’s. Many of Sasanatieng’s metaphors failed to leave a lasting impression on me, remaining charming quirks, rather than resonant ideas.

Clearly, Sasanatieng is not short on ideas. Yet, in this particular instance, those ideas get a running start, but never truly take flight. Still, all told, there is much about Citizen Dog to recommend and it leaves me with the feeling that Sasanatieng is a director to watch in the future.

[***]

Rowland
11-21-2007, 12:56 AM
I haven't seen this movie, but Sasanatieng's Tears of the Black Tiger struck me as more of an experiment than a movie. It lacked a certain conviction beyond all of its stylistic trickery and (I think) exaggerated melodrama conventions. Where the caricature ended and the sincerity began was lost on me, which resulted in an increasingly leaden experience, especially when coupled with some seriously stilted pacing. That said, I did admire all of the delirious expressionist imagery.

Maybe I'll respond differently to Citizen Dog.

D_Davis
11-21-2007, 01:34 AM
Nice review. This has been sitting in my "to watch" pile for a long time. I absolutely love Tears of the Black Tiger, will more than likely make it on my top 10 first time viewings list this year, and from everything I've read about CD, I think I'll dig it.

Sycophant
11-21-2007, 04:38 PM
Nice review. This has been sitting in my "to watch" pile for a long time. I absolutely love Tears of the Black Tiger, will more than likely make it on my top 10 first time viewings list this year, and from everything I've read about CD, I think I'll dig it.I would expect, Davis, that you're totally going to like this when you get to it.

I'm glad you liked it, Spinal. The film managed to thoroughly engage me on both of my viewings, but your complaint about it favoring charming quirks over deep metaphor holds water, though I found the whimsy charming and well-crafted enough to accept their seeming superfluousness. Personally, I also found Jin's journey much better developed and found Jin a more interesting character altogether.

It occurred to me yesterday before I saw this posted that Citizen Dog's classification as a musical might be slightly dubious. I'd make an argument that it was, and was more of one than the recently hyped-as-a-musical rerelease of O, Lucky Man!

Spinal
11-21-2007, 04:49 PM
It occurred to me yesterday before I saw this posted that Citizen Dog's classification as a musical might be slightly dubious. I'd make an argument that it was, and was more of one than the recently hyped-as-a-musical rerelease of O, Lucky Man!

I don't see how it's even remotely close to being a musical apart from the lip-syncing in the opening credits. Not that I minded or cared. I'm just curious what you mean by that.

Sycophant
11-21-2007, 04:54 PM
I don't see how it's even remotely close to being a musical apart from the lip-syncing in the opening credits. Not that I minded or cared. I'm just curious what you mean by that.It opens with a that lip-syncing which--being written specifically for the film--was staged like a musical number, there's the blue dress music that was screen-specific, and there's that rap thing that Pod's grandmother does.

Yeah, it probably doesn't count. I lose points.

Spinal
11-21-2007, 04:56 PM
It opens with a that lip-syncing which--being written specifically for the film--was staged like a musical number, there's the blue dress music that was screen-specific, and there's that rap thing that Pod's grandmother does.

Yeah, it probably doesn't count. I lose points.

I loved that song though. Good stuff.

lovejuice
11-21-2007, 05:58 PM
It opens with a that lip-syncing which--being written specifically for the film--was staged like a musical number, there's the blue dress music that was screen-specific, and there's that rap thing that Pod's grandmother does.


actually if we're referring to the same song, "korn" (before), which are used constantly through-out the movie, it was quite an old thai pop. re-mixed into a better version specially for this movie. if you want to know a tidbit, the song is originally sung by "pod" -- a famous thai singer with the same name as the main character. satsanatiang's initial plan is to have the singer actually portray his hero.

my love for this movie is very hard to argue against or for. it hits me so hard the first time i watched it that i have to rewatch it again right after. this is a movie about a guy trying to win the eccentric heart of the woman he loves. what can be simpler than that?

the setting is this god-damn beautiful city called bangkok, my hometown. the place has been constantly trashed by thai intellectuals as a breeding ground of evil for...like...fucking forever. satsanatiang however captures what make the place so beautiful: its diversity, its chaotic energy, its urban legends, the stories and jokes we thais have been teasing and telling each other for generation.