Match Cut Directorial Canon Consensus - Disney Animated Films

[Watashi]

Since the old Directorial Canon Consensus Thread is dead, I thought I'd revive it for a week for the one consensus I was really looking forward to. I've wanted to participate in this consensus since the idea was first formed nearly two years ago.

If you are unsure what the 46 eligible films are, I've listed them below in order of release.


Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
Pinocchio
Fantasia
Dumbo
Bambi
Saludos Amigos
The Three Caballeros
Make Mine Music
Fun and Fancy Free
Melody Time
The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad
Cinderella
Alice in Wonderland
Peter Pan
Lady and the Tramp
Sleeping Beauty
One Hundred and One Dalmatians
The Sword in the Stone
The Jungle Book
The Aristocats
Robin Hood
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh
The Rescuers
The Fox and the Hound
The Black Cauldron
The Great Mouse Detective
Oliver & Company
The Little Mermaid
The Rescuers Down Under
Beauty and the Beast
Aladdin
The Lion King
Pocahontas
The Hunchback of Notre Dame
Hercules
Mulan
Tarzan
Fantasia 2000
The Emperor's New Groove
Atlantis: The Lost Empire
Lilo & Stitch
Treasure Planet
Brother Bear
Home on the Range
Chicken Little
Meet the Robinsons

[Raiders]

:|:|:|:|

[Watashi]

:|:|:|:|

Que?

[Russ]

So, the animation/live action mix of Song of the South makes it ineligible?

[Watashi]

So, the animation/live action mix of Song of the South makes it ineligible?

According to Disney's site, yes.

[Raiders]

Que?

I was going to start fresh at the new year, starting with the last director we left off with and I was going to kick it off with a Disney week.

But, this is fine I guess. However you want to do it.

[Sycophant]

I'm only going off of what I feel I've seen recently enough or know well enough to give an informed rating to:

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 8.0
Pinocchio - 9.5
Fantasia - 9.0
Dumbo - 9.5
The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad - 7.5
Cinderella - 7.0
Alice in Wonderland - 9.0
Peter Pan - 7.5
Lady and the Tramp - 10.0
Sleeping Beauty - 10.0
One Hundred and One Dalmatians - 8.5
The Sword in the Stone - 7.5
Robin Hood - 10.0
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 9.0
The Rescuers - 7.0
The Great Mouse Detective - 10.0
Oliver & Company - 8.5
Beauty and the Beast - 8.0
Aladdin - 7.5
The Lion King - 9.0
Pocahontas - 2.0
Hercules - 9.0
Mulan - 7.0
Tarzan - 5.5
Fantasia 2000 - 8.0
The Emperor's New Groove - 9.0
Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 5.0
Lilo & Stitch - 8.5
Meet the Robinsons - 6.5

(I ended up being more favorable than I thought.)

Thanks for doing this, Wats. I'd rep you if I could.

[Watashi]

I was going to start fresh at the new year, starting with the last director we left off with and I was going to kick it off with a Disney week.

But, this is fine I guess. However you want to do it.

Considering you didn't reply to my three posts asking if you were going to continue to it, I assumed it was dead.

[Yxklyx]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 6
Fantasia - 9
Dumbo - 7
Bambi - 8
Cinderella - 5
Alice in Wonderland - 6

[Raiders]

Considering you didn't reply to my three posts asking if you were going to continue to it, I assumed it was dead.

Sorry about that. I only recall reading E's posts regarding the subject. It's cool, though.

Are you going to continue to run the project? I am not opposed to doing it again, I was just going to hold off until the new year, but if someone else feels strongly about doing it, I don't mind relinquishing the reins.

[Watashi]

Sorry about that. I only recall reading E's posts regarding the subject. It's cool, though.

Are you going to continue to run the project? I am not opposed to doing it again, I was just going to hold off until the new year, but if someone else feels strongly about doing it, I don't mind relinquishing the reins.

Nah, I just wanted to do this one. I'm not taking over.

[Watashi]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 4
Pinocchio - 10
Fantasia - 5
Dumbo - 6
Bambi - 8
Cinderella - 5
Alice in Wonderland - 9
Peter Pan - 7.5
Lady and the Tramp - 10
Sleeping Beauty - 7
One Hundred and One Dalmatians - 4.5
The Sword in the Stone - 7.5
The Jungle Book - 9
The Aristocats - 4
Robin Hood - 10
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 8.5
The Rescuers - 3
The Fox and the Hound - 7
The Black Cauldron - 5
The Great Mouse Detective - 10
Oliver & Company - 7
The Little Mermaid - 7.5
The Rescuers Down Under - 8.5
Beauty and the Beast - 10
Aladdin - 7
The Lion King - 8
Pocahontas - 2
The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 9.5
Hercules - 7.5
Mulan - 8
Tarzan - 7
Fantasia 2000 - 10
The Emperor's New Groove - 10
Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 6.5
Lilo & Stitch - 8
Treasure Planet - 7.5
Brother Bear - 5
Home on the Range - 1
Meet the Robinsons - 8.5

[Raiders]

Cool. This kind of works best as being a little separated from the rest anyway. I'll have my ballot up shortly.

[Russ]

Fantasia - 5
Fantasia 2000 - 10
:crazy:

[Watashi]

:crazy:

The Rite of Spring brings Fantasia down a lot. It's mind-numbingly dreadful.

While Rhapsody in Blue and The Firebird Suite are some of the most exhilarating and awesome animated sequences I've ever seen.

[Sven]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 7
Pinocchio - 8
Fantasia - 8.5
Dumbo - 10
Bambi - 6
Saludos Amigos - 8
The Three Caballeros - 9
Make Mine Music - 9
Fun and Fancy Free - 9
Melody Time - 9
The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad - 9
Cinderella - 6
Alice in Wonderland - 9
Peter Pan - 6
Lady and the Tramp - 6.5
Sleeping Beauty - 8
One Hundred and One Dalmatians - 7
The Sword in the Stone - 8
The Jungle Book - 7
The Aristocats - 6.5
Robin Hood - 9
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 10
The Rescuers - 9
The Fox and the Hound - 8.5
The Black Cauldron - 6
The Great Mouse Detective - 7.5
Oliver & Company - 7
The Little Mermaid - 6
The Rescuers Down Under - 9
Beauty and the Beast - 6
Aladdin - 6.5
The Lion King - 6
Pocahontas - 3
The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 4
Hercules - 8
Tarzan - 4
The Emperor's New Groove - 6.5
Lilo & Stitch - 8.5
Treasure Planet - 6

You can see where my loyalty lies.

[Sven]

The Rite of Spring brings Fantasia down a lot. It's mind-numbingly dreadful.

I have negative repped you in my mind.

[Raiders]

You can see where my loyalty lies.

Racist.

[Watashi]

I have negative repped you in my mind.

And I have negative mind-repped you for your low Hunchback and Groove ratings.

Ah ha! We are even.

[Sycophant]

The Rite of Spring brings Fantasia down a lot. It's mind-numbingly dreadful.
:eek: I wasn't prepared to read something like this. Least of all from you.

Though "The Firebird Suite" is pretty the best thing in either film, Fantasia just works better.

[Watashi]

I thought my distaste for the original Fantasia was quite known around these parts?

I guess not.

[number8]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 5
Pinocchio - 8
Fantasia - 8
Dumbo - 7
Bambi - 5
The Three Caballeros - 8
Cinderella - 3
Alice in Wonderland - 9
Peter Pan - 4
Lady and the Tramp - 4
Sleeping Beauty - 5
One Hundred and One Dalmatians - 4
The Sword in the Stone - 6
The Jungle Book - 2
The Aristocats - 4
Robin Hood - 8.5
The Black Cauldron - 6
The Great Mouse Detective - 8.5
The Little Mermaid - 5
The Rescuers Down Under - 8
Beauty and the Beast - 5.5
Aladdin - 6
The Lion King - 9
Pocahontas - 2
The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 6
Hercules - 3
Mulan - 7.5
Tarzan - 3
The Emperor's New Groove - 7.5
Lilo & Stitch - 10
Home on the Range - 0
Meet the Robinsons - 3

[Sven]

And I have negative mind-repped you for your low Hunchback and Groove ratings.

Ah ha! We are even.

Groove, I'd like to see again.

Hunchback is a terrible god-awful clunker. Beyond it's animation, which I suppose is serviceable, but hardly expressive, it doesn't work.

[Llopin]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 6
Pinocchio - 9
Fantasia - 8
Dumbo - 8
Bambi - 8
Saludos Amigos - 6
The Three Caballeros - 9
Cinderella - 6
Alice in Wonderland - 7
Peter Pan - 7
Lady and the Tramp - 9
Sleeping Beauty - 6
One Hundred and One Dalmatians - 6
The Sword in the Stone - 6
The Jungle Book - 7
The Aristocats - 5
Robin Hood - 5
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 6
The Rescuers - 5
The Fox and the Hound - 7
The Great Mouse Detective - 8
The Little Mermaid - 9
The Rescuers Down Under - 7
Beauty and the Beast - 8
Aladdin - 8
The Lion King - 8
Pocahontas - 5
The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 5
Hercules - 5
Mulan - 8
Tarzan - 5
Fantasia 2000 - 7
The Emperor's New Groove - 8
Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 4
Lilo & Stitch - 5

[Raiders]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (1937) - 6.0
Pinocchio (1940) - 9.0
Fantasia (1940) - 8.5
Dumbo (1941) - 8.0
Bambi (1942) - 5.5
Saludos Amigos (1942) - 7.5
The Three Caballeros (1944) - 6.5
Make Mine Music (1946) - 6.0
Fun and Fancy Free (1947) - 6.5
Melody Time (1948) - 7.0
The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad (1949) - 7.0
Cinderella (1950) - 5.0
Alice in Wonderland (1951) - 5.0
Peter Pan (1953) - 4.0
The Lady and the Tramp (1955) - 7.0
Sleeping Beauty (1959) - 9.5
One Hundred and One Dalmatians (1961) - 4.5
The Sword in the Stone (1963) - 6.0
The Jungle Book (1967) - 5.5
The Aristocats (1970) - 3.0
Robin Hood (1973) - 7.5
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh (1977) - 7.0
The Rescuers (1977) - 4.5
The Fox and the Hound (1981) - 6.0
The Black Cauldron (1985) - 4.0
The Great Mouse Detective (1986) - 7.0
Oliver & Company (1988) - 3.5
The Little Mermaid (1989) - 8.0
The Rescuers Down Under (1990) - 6.0
Beauty and the Beast (1991) - 8.5
Aladdin (1992) - 5.0
The Lion King (1994) - 7.0
Pocahontas (1995) - 2.5
The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1996) - 5.5
Hercules (1997) - 4.0
Mulan (1998) - 7.5
Tarzan (1999) - 5.0
Fantasia 2000 (1999) - 7.0
The Emperor's New Groove (2000) - 7.5
Atlantis: The Lost Empire (2001) - 4.5
Lilo & Stitch (2002) - 6.0
Meet the Robinsons (2007) - 7.0

[Lucky]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 7
Pinocchio - 7
Fantasia - 9
Dumbo - 8
Bambi - 7
Cinderella - 6
Alice in Wonderland - 6
Peter Pan - 6
Lady and the Tramp - 10
Sleeping Beauty - 10
One Hundred and One Dalmatians - 6
The Sword in the Stone - 7
The Jungle Book - 8
The Aristocats - 4
Robin Hood - 10
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 8
The Little Mermaid - 8
Beauty and the Beast - 9
Aladdin - 8
The Lion King - 8
Pocahontas - 5
The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 7
Hercules - 9
Mulan - 4
Tarzan - 5
Fantasia 2000 - 10
Lilo & Stitch - 5

[origami_mustache]

I'm surprised I've seen as many of these as I have.

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 9
Pinocchio - 9
Fantasia - 9
Dumbo - 7
Bambi - 8
Cinderella - 8
Alice in Wonderland - 9
Peter Pan - 8
Lady and the Tramp - 6
One Hundred and One Dalmatians - 7
The Sword in the Stone - 5
The Jungle Book - 9
The Aristocats - 5
Robin Hood - 9
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 8
The Rescuers - 4
The Fox and the Hound - 6
The Great Mouse Detective - 3
Oliver & Company - 5
The Little Mermaid - 6
The Rescuers Down Under - 3
Beauty and the Beast - 6
Aladdin - 7
The Lion King - 8
Pocahontas - 5
The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 4
Chicken Little - 6

[Ezee E]

Sorry about that. I only recall reading E's posts regarding the subject. It's cool, though.

Are you going to continue to run the project? I am not opposed to doing it again, I was just going to hold off until the new year, but if someone else feels strongly about doing it, I don't mind relinquishing the reins.
I don't want to turn this into anything either, but you didn't reply to me either. Well, you did, but you changed it.

My results will be up in a minute.

[Ezee E]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 9
Pinocchio - 10
Fantasia - 6
Dumbo - 8
Bambi - 9
The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad - 8
Cinderella - 10
Alice in Wonderland - 10
Peter Pan - 8
Lady and the Tramp - 9
Sleeping Beauty - 10
One Hundred and One Dalmatians - 6
The Sword in the Stone - 9
The Jungle Book - 7
The Aristocats - 4
Robin Hood - 7
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 5
The Rescuers - 6
The Fox and the Hound - 8
Oliver & Company - 9
The Little Mermaid - 9
The Rescuers Down Under - 8
Beauty and the Beast - 10
Aladdin - 10
The Lion King - 10
Pocahontas - 6
The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 4
Hercules - 5
The Emperor's New Groove - 4
Lilo & Stitch - 7

[Spinal]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 8
Pinocchio - 8.5
Dumbo - 6.5
Bambi - 5.5
Alice in Wonderland - 8.5
Peter Pan - 5
The Jungle Book - 8
Robin Hood - 7.5
The Fox and the Hound - 7
The Little Mermaid - 7.5
Beauty and the Beast - 7.5
Aladdin - 7
The Lion King - 5.5
Pocahontas - 3
The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 4
Hercules - 4.5
The Emperor's New Groove - 8.5
Chicken Little - 6
Meet the Robinsons - 7.5

There's a bunch that I just don't remember well enough.

[Sycophant]

I'm glad to see Hercules getting some love, though it's not quite enough.

[Spinal]

I'm glad to see Hercules getting some love, though it's not quite enough.

What's so great about Hercules? I thought it was unexceptional.

[Watashi]

The hate for Hunchback is pretty sickening.

[Lucky]

What's so great about Hercules? I thought it was unexceptional.

It scores major points from me for having (arguably) the most complex heroine/antiheroine in a Disney film. Meg more than makes up for the intentionally bland, dimwitted protagonist. I also think Hades is an exceptional Disney villain - the perfect blend of humor and malevolance. It has some incredible action sequences with the Hydra and the Titans springing to mind, and all in all it was fun for me to see the mythical Greek world imagined on the big screen.

[soitgoes...]

Pinocchio (1940) - 8.0
Bambi (1942) - 4.5
Cinderella (1950) - 7.0
Alice in Wonderland (1951) - 4.0
Peter Pan (1953) - 6.5
Lady and the Tramp (1955) - 7.0
Sleeping Beauty (1959) - 7.0
One Hundred and One Dalmatians (1961) - 4.5
The Jungle Book (1967) - 7.0
Robin Hood (1973) - 3.0
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh (1977) - 5.5
The Rescuers (1977) - 6.5
The Fox and the Hound (1981) - 7.5
The Little Mermaid (1989) - 7.5
Beauty and the Beast (1991) - 8.0
Aladdin (1992) - 8.0
The Lion King (1994) - 9.0
Pocahontas (1995) - 5.0
The Hunchback Of Notre Dame (1996) - 4.5
Hercules (1997) - 3.5
Mulan (1998) - 4.5
Tarzan (1999) - 3.0
The Emperor's New Groove (2000) - 6.0
Lilo & Stitch (2002) - 3.5
Chicken Little (2005) - 2.0
Meet the Robinsons (2007) - 7.0

[Mr. Valentine]

The hate for Hunchback is pretty sickening.

agreed.

i'll get my list up tonight.

[Philosophe_rouge]

I'm not too happy with my ratings, I haven't seen many of these films recently. In the case of some it's been more than 10 years...

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs 8
Pinocchio 5
Fantasia 9
Dumbo 7
Bambi 9
The Three Caballeros 6
Cinderella 6
Alice in Wonderland 7
Peter Pan 6
Lady and the Tramp 8
Sleeping Beauty 9.5
One Hundred and One Dalmatians 9
The Jungle Book 8
The Aristocats 7
Robin Hood 8
The Rescuers 7
The Fox and the Hound 7
The Great Mouse Detective 8.5
Oliver & Company 6
The Little Mermaid 9
The Rescuers Down Under 7
Beauty and the Beast 9
Aladdin 8
The Lion King 9.5
Pocahontas 7
The Hunchback of Notre Dame 7
Hercules 9
Mulan 7
Tarzan 6
Fantasia 2000 9
The Emperor's New Groove 6
Lilo & Stitch 8

[Duncan]

I don't remember my childhood.

[Watashi]

I don't remember my childhood.

I've seen nearly all of these for in the past 2-3 years.

[MadMan]

I'm too lazy to revisit much of these. Half of these ratings are from memory/gut feeling/whatever.

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs-7.5
Pinocchio-5.5
Fantasia-10.0
Dumbo-8.0
Bambi-9.0
Cinderella-3.5
Peter Pan-4.0
Lady and the Tramp-7.0
Sleeping Beauty-10.0
One Hundred and One Dalmatians-2.0
The Sword in the Stone-3.0
The Jungle Book-6.5
The Aristocats-7.5
Robin Hood-7.0
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh-9.0
The Rescuers-4.5
The Fox and the Hound-4.5
The Great Mouse Detective-8.5
The Little Mermaid-2.0
The Rescuers Down Under-9.0
Beauty and the Beast-7.0
Aladdin-7.0
The Lion King-10.0
Pocahontas-1.5
Hercules-6.0
Mulan-7.5

I imagine some of these ratings are going to make people go "What?" And of course there is still much I haven't seen or bothered to see.

[Spinal]

The Little Mermaid-2.0

I imagine some of these ratings are going to make people go "What?"

What? :crazy:

[Boner M]

I don't remember my childhood.
Ditto.

I'd like to see The Emperor's New Groove, though.

[Sycophant]

Disney movies are almost all I can remember from my childhood. :)


:cry:

[Spinal]

Ditto.

I'd like to see The Emperor's New Groove, though.

For something involving David Spade in a critical role, it's actually very, very good.

[Boner M]

I've heard nothing but good things.

[Mr. Valentine]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 7
Pinocchio - 8
Fantasia - 6
Dumbo - 9
Bambi - 7.5
Fun and Fancy Free - 6.5
Cinderella - 8
Alice in Wonderland - 9
Peter Pan - 7.5
Lady and the Tramp - 7
Sleeping Beauty - 6.5
One Hundred and One Dalmatians - 7.5
The Sword in the Stone - 7
The Jungle Book - 8
The Aristocats - 6.5
Robin Hood - 9
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 9
The Rescuers - 7
The Fox and the Hound - 5.5
The Black Cauldron - 6.5
The Great Mouse Detective - 7.5
Oliver & Company - 6
The Little Mermaid - 10
The Rescuers Down Under - 7
Beauty and the Beast - 10
Aladdin - 9.5
The Lion King - 10
Pocahontas - 6.5
The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 9
Hercules - 6.5
Mulan - 8.5
The Emperor's New Groove - 5.5
Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 8
Lilo & Stitch - 7.5
Chicken Little - 6.5
Meet the Robinsons - 8

[number8]

I'm encouraged that only Wats and I have seen Home on the Range. I knew I like you people for something.

[MadMan]

What? :crazy:I hate that movie. If it wasn't for some of the songs and the characters of Flounder and Sebastian I would have given it a 0/10.

[Sycophant]

I'm encouraged that only Wats and I have seen Home on the Range. I knew I like you people for something.
As a former (and kinda current) self-identifying Disney fan, I've nearly watched it a couple times out of obligation. But good Lord... I just can't.

[Watashi]

I refuse to see Chicken Little.

[MadMan]

Yeah most of the more recent Disney animated films on this list I won't be seeing. Its obvious that PIXAR is far suprerior and that even Dreamworks is better. Kinda sad considering how much I love 2D animation, but eventually the new form of technology always takes out the old.

[Sycophant]

Yeah most of the more recent Disney animated films on this list I won't be seeing. Its obvious that PIXAR is far suprerior and that even Dreamworks is better. Kinda sad considering how much I love 2D animation, but eventually the new form of technology always takes out the old.Frog Princess will rule. And the only thing I've seen DreamWorks do that I liked more than Atlantis was The Prince of Egypt, but even Disney was passable then.

[Mysterious Dude]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs 7.5
Pinocchio 6.5
Fantasia 9.5
Dumbo 8.0
Bambi 9.0
Cinderella 7.0
Alice in Wonderland 7.5
Peter Pan 6.5
Lady and the Tramp 8.5
Sleeping Beauty 7.0
One Hundred and One Dalmatians 7.0
The Sword in the Stone 6.5
The Jungle Book 7.5
Robin Hood 5.5
The Rescuers 6.0
The Fox and the Hound 6.0
The Black Cauldron 4.5
The Great Mouse Detective 6.5
Oliver & Company 7.5
The Little Mermaid 6.0
The Rescuers Down Under 7.0
Beauty and the Beast 7.0
Aladdin 7.0
The Lion King 7.0
Pocahontas 4.0
The Hunchback of Notre Dame 7.0
Hercules 5.5
Mulan 5.0
Tarzan 6.5
Fantasia 2000 6.5
The Emperor's New Groove 6.0
Treasure Planet 6.5
Chicken Little 6.0

[Melville]

I don't remember my childhood.


Ditto.

Indeed. I didn't realize how little I remember these movies until I actually read through the list.

[jenniferofthejungle]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 8.5
Pinocchio - 9
Fantasia - 6
Dumbo - 8
Bambi - 8
Cinderella - 10
Alice in Wonderland - 8
Peter Pan - 7.5
Lady and the Tramp - 8
Sleeping Beauty - 10
One Hundred and One Dalmatians - 8
The Sword in the Stone - 6
The Jungle Book - 7
The Aristocats - 7
Robin Hood - 7
The Black Cauldron - 7
The Little Mermaid - 9
The Rescuers Down Under - 7.5
Beauty and the Beast - 9
Aladdin - 9
The Lion King - 10
Pocahontas- 3
The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 6
Mulan - 8
Tarzan - 7
The Emperor's New Groove - 8
Brother Bear - 6
Meet the Robinsons - 6

[soitgoes...]

I refuse to see Chicken Little.
You're a smarter man than I. My old roommate rented it, and I had nothing better to watch. After finishing it, it wa apparent that watching nothing would've been more entertaining.

[DSNT]

Wow, I just barely remember a lot of these.

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 7
Pinocchio - 8
Fantasia - 6
Dumbo - 5
Bambi - 8.5
Cinderella - 7
Alice in Wonderland - 9.5
Peter Pan - 9
Lady and the Tramp - 5.5
Sleeping Beauty - 8
One Hundred and One Dalmatians - 7
The Sword in the Stone - 3
The Jungle Book - 4
The Aristocats - 5
Robin Hood - 4
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 6
The Rescuers - 5
The Fox and the Hound - 3
The Little Mermaid - 7
Beauty and the Beast - 8
Aladdin - 6
The Lion King - 7.5
Lilo & Stitch 7.5

[Watashi]

Wow, I just barely remember a lot of these.

Lady and the Tramp - 5.5
The Sword in the Stone - 3
The Jungle Book - 4
Robin Hood - 4
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 6

:|

Looks like your memory needs a check-up.

[megladon8]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 10
Pinocchio - 10
Dumbo - 8.5
Cinderella - 10
Alice in Wonderland - 9
Peter Pan - 8.5
One Hundred and One Dalmatians - 8
The Jungle Book - 7
Robin Hood - 7
The Fox and the Hound - 9.5
The Great Mouse Detective - 8
The Little Mermaid - 10
Beauty and the Beast - 10
Aladdin - 10
The Lion King - 10
Pocahontas - 6
The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 6.5
Hercules - 7.5
The Emperor's New Groove - 9



Wow...I can't believe how many I haven't seen.

[Raiders]

What's with all the N/A's? Why not just not list those films. That way makes it awful convoluted.

[kamran]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 9.0
Pinocchio - 10.0
Fantasia - 7.0
Bambi - 7.0
The Three Caballeros - 9.0
Cinderella - 8.0
Alice in Wonderland - 7.0
Peter Pan - 7.5
Lady and the Tramp - 9.0
Sleeping Beauty - 7.0
One Hundred and One Dalmatians - 7.0
The Jungle Book - 6.5
Robin Hood - 9.0
Oliver & Company - 6.5
The Little Mermaid - 7.0
Beauty and the Beast - 7.0
Aladdin - 5.5
The Lion King - 6.0
Pocahontas - 4.5
The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 7.0
Hercules - 7.0
Mulan - 7.5
Tarzan - 7.0
Fantasia 2000 - 7.5
The Emperor's New Groove - 8.0
Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 4.0
Lilo & Stitch - 6.5

[monolith94]

Pinocchio - 9.5
Fantasia - 9.5
Dumbo - 9.5
Lady and the Tramp - 10
Sleeping Beauty - 10
One Hundred and One Dalmatians - 8.5
The Sword in the Stone - 9
Robin Hood - 8.5
The Great Mouse Detective - 8.5
Oliver & Company - 8
The Little Mermaid - 9
The Rescuers Down Under - 9
Beauty and the Beast - 9.5
Aladdin - 9
The Lion King - 9
Pocahontas - 3
The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 2
Fantasia 2000 - 9
The Emperor's New Groove - 9
Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 9
Lilo & Stitch - 9
Treasure Planet - 8.5

A great many I had to exclude because I hadn't seen them since childhood.

[Russ]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs 7.5
Pinocchio 7.0
Fantasia 10.0
Dumbo 8.0
Bambi 9.0
Cinderella 7.0
Lady and the Tramp 8.5
Sleeping Beauty 6.5
One Hundred and One Dalmatians 8.0
The Sword in the Stone 5.5
The Jungle Book 7.5
The Aristocats 6.0
The Little Mermaid 7.5
Beauty and the Beast 8.0
Aladdin 7.0
The Lion King 7.5
The Hunchback of Notre Dame 6.0
Hercules 5.5
Tarzan 5.0
Fantasia 2000 7.0
The Emperor's New Groove 7.5
Atlantis: The Lost Empire 6.0
Treasure Planet 5.5

[MadMan]

So I guess the votes weren't counted and stuff? Odd.

[Watashi]

So I guess the votes weren't counted and stuff? Odd.

I haven't had any time. I'm waiting for my new laptop.

[Raiders]

Does this mean I can give you crap now?

[Watashi]

Does this mean I can give you crap now?

I never gave you any crap.

[MadMan]

I haven't had any time. I'm waiting for my new laptop.Excuses, excuses :|




;) :P


Does this mean I can give you crap now?Heh.

[Sycophant]

I haven't had any time. I'm waiting for my new laptop.
I trust it's okay that I updated my list by editing the post. You haven't done any tabulation yet, right?

[soitgoes...]

Updated original post to include both The Rescuers and The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh.

[soitgoes...]

Perhaps a bump is in order before this gets lost in obscurity?

[eternity]

It appears Pixar is ineligible too.

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs: 7.5
Pinocchio: 7.0
Fantasia: 9.5
Dumbo: 8.0
Bambi: 5.0
The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad: 8.0
Cinderella: 7.5
Alice in Wonderland: 8.5
Peter Pan: 8.0
Lady and the Tramp: 6.5
Sleeping Beauty: 6.0
One Hundred and One Dalmatians: 8.5
The Jungle Book: 8.0
The Aristocats: 7.5
Robin Hood: 9.0
The Fox and the Hound: 5.0
The Little Mermaid: 7.5
Beauty and the Beast: 8.0
Aladdin: 8.5
The Lion King: 7.5
Pocahontas: 5.0
The Hunchback of Notre Dame: 5.5
Hercules: 5.0
Mulan: 5.0
Tarzan: 3.0
The Emperor's New Groove: 8.5
Atlantis: The Lost Empire: 4.0
Lilo & Stitch: 7.0
Treasure Planet: 8.0
Brother Bear: 4.0
Home on the Range: 2.5
Chicken Little: 4.0
Meet the Robinsons: 5.0

[Fezzik]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs: 7.0
Pinocchio: 8.5
Fantasia: 9.0
Dumbo: 8.5
Bambi: 7.5
Saludos Amigos: 6.0
The Three Caballeros: 6.0
Make Mine Music: 6.5
Fun and Fancy Free: 7.5
Melody Time: 5.5
The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad: 9.0
Cinderella: 6.5
Alice in Wonderland: 6.5
Peter Pan: 8.0
Lady and the Tramp: 8.5
Sleeping Beauty: 10.0
One Hundred and One Dalmatians: 7.5
The Sword in the Stone: 6.5
The Jungle Book: 6.0
The Aristocats: 6.5
Robin Hood: 7.0
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh: 8.0
The Rescuers: 10.0
The Fox and the Hound: 6.5
The Black Cauldron: 6.0
The Great Mouse Detective: 9.0
Oliver & Company: 7.0
The Little Mermaid: 8.5
The Rescuers Down Under: 8.5
Beauty and the Beast: 10.0
Aladdin: 9.0
The Lion King: 10.0
Pocahontas: 7.0
The Hunchback of Notre Dame: 8.5
Hercules: 6.5
Mulan: 8.0
Tarzan: 7.0
Fantasia 2000: 8.5
The Emperor's New Groove: 9.5
Atlantis: The Lost Empire: 4.5
Lilo & Stitch: 9.5
Treasure Planet: 4.0
Brother Bear: 5.0
Home on the Range: 1.5
Chicken Little: 4.0
Meet the Robinsons: 7.5

[Ezee E]

I think the amount of movies Wats would have to enter scared him from completing the project. It's practically like doing three directors not named Hitchcock, Ford, Allen, or Griffith.

[Ivan Drago]

Is there still time to put in ratings?

[soitgoes...]

Is there still time to put in ratings?
I think we're waiting for The Princess and the Frog to come out at the end of next year in order for this consensus to be as all-encompassing as possible. So post away!!!

[Ivan Drago]

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs 6
Pinocchio 6.5
Fantasia 6
Cinderella 5
Alice in Wonderland 6
Peter Pan 7
Lady and the Tramp 5
Sleeping Beauty 6
One Hundred and One Dalmatians 8
The Jungle Book 8
The Aristocats 6.5
Robin Hood 7
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh 7
The Rescuers 6
The Fox and the Hound 6.5
The Black Cauldron 5
The Great Mouse Detective 8
Oliver & Company 6.5
The Little Mermaid 7.5
The Rescuers Down Under 6
Beauty and the Beast 8
Aladdin 7.5
The Lion King 9
Pocahontas 4
The Hunchback of Notre Dame 7
Hercules 6
Mulan 6.5
Tarzan 6.5
The Emperor's New Groove 8

[Rowland]

Bumping this because I've been on a bit of a Disney kick lately, watching many of the classics I've somehow never seen while revisiting others that I haven't seen since I was very young, and I like having all these lists to compare with my reactions. So far, I'm most surprised by my enthusiastic response to 101 Dalmatians proving to be something of a minority position, and pleased to discover that I'm not as alone as I anticipated concerning my unresponsiveness towards Bambi. My ratings only reflect the films I've recently watched:

Dumbo - 7.5
Bambi - 5.0
Lady and the Tramp - 6.5
Sleeping Beauty - 8.5
One Hundred and One Dalmatians - 8.0
The Aristocats - 5.0

[Mysterious Dude]

I think the amount of movies Wats would have to enter scared him from completing the project. It's practically like doing three directors not named Hitchcock, Ford, Allen, or Griffith.
He's probably still waiting for the laptop. Dell takes forever to deliver those things.