Alicia Keys vs. The White Stripes

[Qrazy]

The age old battle comes to a head. Let your voices be heard.

[number8]

One is an accomplished soul/jazz singer adored by Bob Dylan.

The other is part of a pop rock band adored by teeny boppers.

All I'm sayin'...

[Malickfan]

What about The Black Keys? With Alicia Key's booty?

[Sven]

One is an accomplished soul/jazz singer adored by Bob Dylan.

The other is part of a pop rock band adored by teeny boppers.

All I'm sayin'...

Appeal to authority much? Did you know that White has played with Dylan on multiple occasions?

The White Stripes are great. Keys seems fine, don't know much about her. Where's the beef here?

[D_Davis]

I don't like the White Stripes. Boring, generic garage rock. I'd rather listen to the old classics on the Pebbles compilations.

I don't really like Alecia Keyes either. She's okay for modern RnB, but I don't really feel anything special from her. For a female singer songwriter, I prefer to listen to someone like Nora Jones or Neko Case.

So is neither an option?

[Winston*]

So is neither an option?

NO!

[Sven]

I don't like the White Stripes. Boring, generic garage rock. I'd rather listen to the old classics on the Pebbles compilations.

You say "generic", I say "true to their roots". I don't see how one could write off White's mad riffing skills.

[Malickfan]

NO!

Alicia Keys. Because of the booty.

[Ezee E]

I like them both. The White Stripes last album isn't exactly a teenybopper album either, I don't know how that idea came about.

[Spinal]

The White Stripes. The one that does not bore me.

[Duncan]

I actually kind of like Alicia Keys, but I don't think I've ever seen or heard her outside of live performances on TV. I think she's a terrific performer.

[Benny Profane]

The White Stripes. The one that does not bore me.

Yep.


And Nora Jones is the equivalent of 10 sleeping pills.

[Wryan]

I like both an awful amount.

[Benny Profane]

I like both an awful amount.

Typical commie fence-sitter.

[Malickfan]

And Nora Jones is the equivalent of 10 sleeping pills.

Every song of hers sounds the same.

[Henry Gale]

I have heard at least a couple of albums by both but I don't really listen to either too much.

The Raconteurs, on the other hand, I quite like.

[MadMan]

What about The Black Keys? With Alicia Key's booty?Heh. As in the blues/rock duo that's pretty awesome? They're better than both the White Stripes and Alica Keys.

As for the actual question, the White Stripes. By a lot. I also agree that Nora Jones is quite boring. Her music puts me to sleep.

[Justin]

I think Alicia Keys is painfully boring.

The White Stripes on the other hand, kick ass.

[number8]

Heh. As in the blues/rock duo that's pretty awesome? They're better than both the White Stripes and Alica Keys.

Finally, some sensible truth out of you. :P

[Scar]

When I hear Jack White and virtuoso in the same sentence, I feel like bludgeoning something or someone.

[MadMan]

Finally, some sensible truth out of you. :PWhatevers :P More people need to listen to the Black Keys. I want to get my hands on their other albums after listening to Magic Potion, which was a great disc.

[Kurious Jorge v3.1]

The White Stripes rool, Alicia Keys drool

[ledfloyd]

One is an accomplished soul/jazz singer adored by Bob Dylan.

The other is part of a pop rock band adored by teeny boppers.

All I'm sayin'...
bob dylan is a fan of both.

[number8]

bob dylan is a fan of both.

So are teeny boppers.

[Qrazy]

So are teeny boppers.

Thereby negating your original post?

[number8]

Thereby negating your original post?

Thereby solidifying my original post.

[Qrazy]

One is an accomplished soul/jazz singer adored by Bob Dylan.

The other is part of a pop rock band adored by teeny boppers.

All I'm sayin'...


One is an accomplished soul/jazz singer adored by teeny boppers.

The other is part of a pop rock band adored by Bob Dylan.

All I'm sayin'...

This is not solidification.

[Benny Profane]

Oh snap.

Nicely done Qrazy.

[Ezee E]

haha